Cafe Colonial

73 E Houston St Ste 1 New York, NY map / directions subway directions send flowers here (212) 274-0044  

Hours Currently OPEN

Cafe Colonial is a International, Caribbean, and Breakfast restaurant where most Menuism users came for fun with friends, paid between $25 and $50, and tipped between 15% to 18%.

People describe this restaurant as and [ tag it ]

Stats

  • # of dishes people have entered : 32
  • # who want to try this restaurant : 0
  • # who have favorited this restaurant : 2
  • # sites linking here : 1

Overall

***1/2

3.5 avg. based on 4 ratings & 2 reviews

Rate It!

(Your Rating and Try List will show up under the My Journal tab)

Reviews

Be a food critic: Write a review

2 reviews

Award_star_gold First reviewed by:  parkhyein
Jul 3, 2007 Link

Great people-watching, pretty good food

With a prime spot at the corner of Houston and Elizabeth, Cafe Colonial doesn’t have to serve up outstanding food, although brunch is apparently terrific. I was there for dinner on a warm summer evening, and the food was more than passable – but there’s no way it could rival the spectacle of Nolita’s passersby.

My friend and I each enjoyed a ‘Mexican Bloody Mary’, a mix of vodka and tequila with perfectly piquant tomato juice and spices. It was an ideal way to cool down after wandering around the Lower East Side in the heat. We shared some pão de queijo, because we always used to eat that deliriously cheesy bread at our favorite Brazilian restaurant in Beijing, and Cafe Colonial’s version was even better, piping hot and indulgent.

Somehow, we still found room to split a bacon cheeseburger and spinach and goat cheese salad. The burger was well cooked and juicy, with extra crispy bacon (definitely the way I like it), but it was nothing out of the ordinary, just standard bistro fare, really. The salad was a bit more unusual, coated as it was in a thin guacamole. It was quite good, and I would order it again on its own.

The service was quick and unobtrusive, and my only complaint was the bill – average for New York, perhaps, but unmerited by the food’s quality. Still, I would return here, though probably only for brunch or lunch.

What I ate:
  • ****

    These pastry-like balls of cheese bread are definitely sinful, but incredibly worthy of indulgence.

  • ***

    It’s usually not a good sign when the menu has to modify “Hamburger”, but Cafe Colonial puts out a good rendition of a traditional bistro burger. I probably wouldn’t order one here again, though, just because I can get them better and cheaper elsewhere.

  • ****

    This salad of fresh spinach comes with a nice amount of goat cheese and an interesting guacamole dressing. It is refreshing, and I’ll likely order it on a return visit.

Extras:
I came here for
fun with friends
My meal cost
between $25 and $50
I tipped
between 15% to 18%
Was this helpful?
Yes No (6 of 6 people found this review helpful)  
Add a Comment
Jun 12, 2007 Link

Where I fell in love with Brazilian food. I've since had...

Where I fell in love with Brazilian food. I’ve since had better, but you never forget your first.

Was this helpful?
Yes No (1 of 1 people found this review helpful)  
Add a Comment

Popular Dishes on the Menu

These are dishes contributed by Menuism users, either entered directly, as part of a restaurant review, or as part of an image upload.

Top Dishes from Menuism Users

32 Dishes - Click to see, rate, add, or edit dishes

Did you eat at this restaurant? Are you a food lover? Have an opinion to share?

Write a review