Welcome! You're viewing El Faro on Menuism.
Menuism is your personalized dining journal and restaurant exploration guide – you can keep track of the restaurants you love and want to try, and be a food critic by writing reviews and keeping private notes about your dining experiences. Give it a try!
- Have you been to El Faro? Rate it or add it to your favorites or try list.
- Want to remember something about El Faro? Add a private note and it'll show up whenever you see this listing.
- Not what you're looking for? Browse more restaurants in New York, NY »
El Faro
823 Greenwich St New York, NY (212) 929-8210| Website: | http://elfaro.citysearch.com |
El Faro is a Spanish, Seafood, and Mediterranean restaurant where most Menuism users came for a family meal, paid between $25 and $50, and tipped more than 18%.
People describe this restaurant as [ tag it ]
Stats
- # of dishes people have entered : 82
- # who want to try this restaurant : 2
- # who have favorited this restaurant : 2
- # sites linking here : 0
Reviews
Be a food critic: Write a review
A Spanish Stalwart
El Faro has occupied the corner of Horatio and Greenwich since the meatpacking district actually merited its name. For decades, this Galician-owned treasure has turned out spot-on preparations of classic Spanish dishes in a cozy, semi-subterranean space that evokes the best local restaurants in smaller Iberian cities.
When I need a paella fix – or, even better, have a craving for unsurpassed gambas al ajillo – El Faro stands like a beacon, drawing me closer until I have to submit to high prices and too-formal service to get my fill. Still, I’m never disappointed here, and no one else I know is either.
-
Shrimp al Ajillo
A terrific rendition of this incredible classic – small shrimp, bubbling in a clay casserole filled with hot sauce and an immense amount of garlic. New York’s other ‘Spanish’ restaurants need to come study in El Faro’s kitchen for this one.
-
Paella a la Marinera
A luscious seafood paella that will transport you to the Mediterranean instantaneously.
-
Tortilla Española
The best tortilla española in New York.
- I came here for
- a family meal
- My meal cost
- between $25 and $50
- I tipped
- more than 18%
Did you eat at this restaurant? Are you a food lover? Have an opinion to share?
Write a review

First reviewed by:

