This was my second visit to Nicky’s, previously it was however during lunch. This is definitely a hot place for friends to meet as we ran into the crown as soon as we walked in! That is always a good sign to me.

We were seated promptly and the hostess explained the evening specials. On a Friday night in Wisconsin where is the place to be? … a Fish Fry! Nicky’s fits into that category with its own special fish dishes to tempt your pallet!

Even though the restaurant was busy, we were taken care of very well. Our drinks arrived in a very timely manner – even considering the crowd that was at the bar!

One of the other things (aside from the great ambiance of this classic building) is the White Cheese Curds. In Wisconsin, it is all about the cheese. I first fell in love with White Cheese Curds at the resort I worked at a few years ago and have found that these are hard to find! When I discover someplace that serves White Cheese Curds, they score a few extra points in my book!

Nicky’s features some tantelizing sandwiches, but are most famous for their Muffuletta sandwiches. They feature a traditional Muffuletta as well as a chicken variety that is fabulous. There are many more sandwiches on the menu that I want to try, so I will have to come back often!

The only downfall of the entire dining experience was that the fries were not the same as they were before. When we were here for lunch before, the fries were skin on seasoned fries that were fabulous! The fries we had this time were a regular french fry with a peppery seasoning on them. I thought they were “ok” but my husband did not care for them at all. Next time, we will ask for no pepper on our fries!