20 W Oakland Ave ( )
Oakland, NJ 07436
August 29, 20112.0
So sad to find that Tonys Brother’s has been sold. Husband came home with a pizza a few months ago, and said that he didn’t see one familiar face when he went in for pick-up. (The pizza he brought home? Meh. We won’t be back.)
For 20 years we were loyal to Tony’s, passing up 10 or more restaurants on our way, and despite a 20 minute round-trip- because they were THAT GOOD. They had the best pizza around, delicious specials, friendly owners and staff (which I will miss the most), and their kitchen was immaculate!
Wish I knew if they opened at a new location, under another name.
December 25, 20095.0
I’ve been going there most of my life and have never had a bad dish. Chicken franchese and the pasta dishes are my favs, but their eggplant entrees, salads, and subs are also terrific. Be sure not to disregard the specials!
The ingredients all seem to be fresh from the farm and are presented without fuss. Anybody’s Italian grandma would be proud of the true maranara sauce that makes you want to lick your plate clean.
Go hungry… the bread is hot out of the oven when you sit down!
The only drawback I can think of – it’s BYOB.
April 16, 20084.0
I’ve eaten here for years and thier consistency is key to what brings me back… if it aint broke don’t fix it. Excellent pie.
classic pepperoni baby! Bubbly crust, old school Joisey like it should be.
These dishes from the Tony Brothers Pizza & Restaurant menu are contributed by Menuism users directly, as part of a restaurant review, or as part of an image upload.