trufflupagus's Reviews

  • Cafe Colonial Add to Try List
    Jul 3, 2007 Link

    Great people-watching, pretty good food

    With a prime spot at the corner of Houston and Elizabeth, Cafe Colonial doesn’t have to serve up outstanding food, although brunch is apparently terrific. I was there for dinner on a warm summer evening, and the food was more than passable – but there’s no way it could rival the spectacle of Nolita’s passersby.

    My friend and I each enjoyed a ‘Mexican Bloody Mary’, a mix of vodka and tequila with perfectly piquant tomato juice and spices. It was an ideal way to cool down after wandering around the Lower East Side in the heat. We shared some pão de queijo, because we always used to eat that deliriously cheesy bread at our favorite Brazilian restaurant in Beijing, and Cafe Colonial’s version was even better, piping hot and indulgent.

    Somehow, we still found room to split a bacon cheeseburger and spinach and goat cheese salad. The burger was well cooked and juicy, with extra crispy bacon (definitely the way I like it), but it was nothing out of the ordinary, just standard bistro fare, really. The salad was a bit more unusual, coated as it was in a thin guacamole. It was quite good, and I would order it again on its own.

    The service was quick and unobtrusive, and my only complaint was the bill – average for New York, perhaps, but unmerited by the food’s quality. Still, I would return here, though probably only for brunch or lunch.

    What I ate:
    • ****

      These pastry-like balls of cheese bread are definitely sinful, but incredibly worthy of indulgence.

    • ***

      It’s usually not a good sign when the menu has to modify “Hamburger”, but Cafe Colonial puts out a good rendition of a traditional bistro burger. I probably wouldn’t order one here again, though, just because I can get them better and cheaper elsewhere.

    • ****

      This salad of fresh spinach comes with a nice amount of goat cheese and an interesting guacamole dressing. It is refreshing, and I’ll likely order it on a return visit.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    fun with friends
    My meal cost
    between $25 and $50
    I tipped
    between 15% to 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (6 of 6 people found this review helpful)  
    Add a Comment
  • Spicy & Tasty Add to Try List
    Jun 29, 2007 Link

    Some more great dishes

    My follow-up review for this restaurant. Read my previous review for this restaurant here.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      Perfectly tender white fish slices, sauteed in brown sauce with ginger and scallion. This dish is resplendent – one of my new Spicy and Tasty favorites!

    • ***

      Fresher and less gummy than the traditional preparation. These thin noodles with sesame and lots of green and crunchy garnishes are actually quite good.

    • Acx-kijlur3i65aby-gaa880x80
      *****

      Ask them to add fresh garlic to the cucumber with sesame oil, and you’ll arrive at a dish that I used to order for lunch all the time in China. It definitely helps beat the heat of all the fiery peppers!

    Extras:
    I came here for
    a family meal
    My meal cost
    between $10 and $25
    I tipped
    between 15% to 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (5 of 5 people found this review helpful)  
    Add a Comment
  • J.G. Melon Add to Try List
    Jun 18, 2007 Link

    Terrific Burgers, Great Fries

    The problem with many of New York’s best burger joints (Shake Shack excepted) is the lackluster fries that accompany the pièce de resistance. JG Melon avoids this quandary by turning out incredibly crisp and moist cottage fries alongside their burgers. The burgers themselves are on the small side, so it’s good that the fries are so stellar or most customers would leave without feeling full. A cup of delicious chili is also an option here, in case you’re not in the mood for fries (though who’s ever not?).

    I’ve only ever frequented JG’s in the wee hours, before heading home after a night of carousing. The place is still lively even toward closing time, and the old-school pub ambience is easy to negotiate even when you don’t have all your wits about you. And the perfectly done burgers and unique fries will definitely restore you for whatever comes next.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      One of the best burgers in New York. Sure, it’s not Shake Shack, but it’s open year-round, and it’s indoors!

    • *****

      Oh, these are delicious. Can you find these anywhere else? I haven’t…

    • ***

      Pretty good, but personally I’d rather attempt another burger than settle for some chili.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    fun with friends
    My meal cost
    between $10 and $25
    I tipped
    between 15% to 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (5 of 5 people found this review helpful)  
    Add a Comment
  • Magnolia Bakery Add to Try List
    Jun 18, 2007 Link

    Beware: Pretty Cupcakes are Worse than They Appear

    Magnolia Bakery has risen to fame on the back of its vanilla and chocolate cupcakes, spawning dozens of imitators around New York, and even more, I’m sure, across the country. However, these sugar bombs explode in your mouth and instantly make you feel sick – at least, that’s what they did to me. More disgusting than delicious by far, despite how pretty they are.

    Fortunately, however, my friend insisted I try their red velvet cake (yum!) and the banana pudding (super yum!), both of which are also probably famous in their own right by now. Don’t brave a line for either of them, but if you come at an off time of day, definitely take the time to grab either of those treats – and don’t be tempted by the soldierly cupcakes manning their posts. Consider this fair warning.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      This pudding is terrific: cold, smooth, and punctuated with Nilla Wafers to really bring you back to childhood.

    • ****

      This is the red velvet cake that started New York’s obsession with the dessert. So it’s worth trying it here – it’s pretty delicious.

    • *

      These are just so cloying and horrible.

    • *

      Even worse than the chocolate cupcakes, despite the fact that I pretty much universally like vanilla better.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    fun with friends
    My meal cost
    less than $10
    I tipped
    less than 15%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (7 of 7 people found this review helpful)  
    Add a Comment
  • El Faro Add to Try List
    Jun 18, 2007 Link

    A Spanish Stalwart

    El Faro has occupied the corner of Horatio and Greenwich since the meatpacking district actually merited its name. For decades, this Galician-owned treasure has turned out spot-on preparations of classic Spanish dishes in a cozy, semi-subterranean space that evokes the best local restaurants in smaller Iberian cities.

    When I need a paella fix – or, even better, have a craving for unsurpassed gambas al ajillo – El Faro stands like a beacon, drawing me closer until I have to submit to high prices and too-formal service to get my fill. Still, I’m never disappointed here, and no one else I know is either.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      A terrific rendition of this incredible classic – small shrimp, bubbling in a clay casserole filled with hot sauce and an immense amount of garlic. New York’s other ‘Spanish’ restaurants need to come study in El Faro’s kitchen for this one.

    • *****

      A luscious seafood paella that will transport you to the Mediterranean instantaneously.

    • *****

      The best tortilla española in New York.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    a family meal
    My meal cost
    between $25 and $50
    I tipped
    more than 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (6 of 6 people found this review helpful)  
    Add/Show Comments (2)
  • Cafe Habana Add to Try List
    Jun 17, 2007 Link

    Corner Cuban-Mexican Cafe of My Dreams

    When I go too long without savoring some of Cafe Habana’s mouthwatering grilled corn with chili powder, cotija cheese, and lime, it starts showing up in my dreams with disturbing regularity. Eventually I head downtown and brave the crowds to snag a table at this tiny eatery, and I remember that it’s not just the corn that’s incredible. The salads are fresh and complex, the tlacoyo de tresmarias a perfect indulgence with goat cheese and masa, the skirt steak smoky and flavorful.

    Wash it all down with some tall mojitos, and then move on out, because someone is definitely waiting for your table.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      The most incredible combination of corn, cheese, and spiciness ever concocted, this grilled corn is the stuff that dreams are made of – all too literally, in my case.

    • ****

      This salad is a great entree when you want to save all your indulgence for the corn. The mango and jicama add a nice sweetness and crunch respectively to the basic salad, which is always composed of perfect produce.

    • *****

      This ‘boat’ made of masa contains a wealth of goat cheese that warms the insides and the soul. There’s enough on the plate for two, if you’re stoic enough to attempt sharing.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    fun with friends
    My meal cost
    between $10 and $25
    I tipped
    between 15% to 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (4 of 4 people found this review helpful)  
    Add a Comment
  • Tia Pol Add to Try List
    Jun 17, 2007 Link

    Incredible Tapas in a Worthy Space

    Tía Pol represents the absolute summit of tapas in this city. The friendly owners took a tiny, oblong space and converted it into a unique bastion of Spanish snacking, with less than a dozen tables, mostly two-tops with high stools, and a packed bar, where I often end up eating instead of waiting for a table to open up. The wait for a spot just at the bar can sometimes take up to an hour, so it’s great that it’s such an enjoyable option to eat right there.

    Their house specialties, like chorizo and chocolate sandwiches, fried garbanzos, and patatas bravas, are basically perfect, and consistently executed with excellence, but that ethos pervades virtually the entire menu, and it’s hard to go wrong.

    The atmosphere successfully and naturally evokes a hip, innovative tapas bar in Madrid, and that, along with the knowledgeable and cool servers, the incredible food, and the exquisite wine list, with cheap and terrific labels by the glass, contributes to making Tía Pol one of my absolute all-time favorite places to eat.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      The lunchtime version of evening’s chorizo and chocolate tapas, the Nino Rebelde is a larger sandwich perfect for when you’re feeling rebellious in the middle of the afternoon.

    • **

      I expected these packets of artichoke and manchego wrapped in jamón serrano to be better than they were. The ham was a little tough, and the flavors didn’t come together in a pleasant way. Sadly, they’re to be avoided.

    • *****

      Terrific assortment of interesting olives.

    • *****

      Ethereally delicious croquettes. Not heavy or greasy, just hot, bursting with flavor, and full of surprises.

    • ****

      Marcona almonds are always good, but it’s not like they had to do anything but pour them from a tin.

    • ****

      White asparagus topped with smooth mayo and briny caviar. Delicious combination of earth and sea.

    • ****

      Nicely prepared chorizo.

    • *****

      Wonderful grilled shrimp. Your hands will end up messy as hell from peeling them, but it’s entirely worth it for the juicy, sweet meat inside the shells.

    • *****

      These are the most perfect patatas bravas this side of the Atlantic, and among the best ones on either side. Chunks of potato, done to exactly the right crispness, tossed in a spicy aioli that will make you forget ketchup ever existed. A must-order.

    • *****

      One of Tía Pol’s signature dishes, these slightly spicy garbanzos are possibly the best bar food ever invented. Reminiscent of popcorn but a million times better and more interesting.

    • *****

      This is one cheese plate that never disappoints. With regional varieties from all over the peninsula, it offers a diversity of flavor and sharpness. The plate is always nicely dressed with breads, membrillo, and almonds or other accompaniments, as well.

    • *****

      Incredibly inventive addictive sandwich of thinly sliced chorizo, layered above a shmear of bittersweet chocolate, on an open-face baguette. This definitely appears in my dreams from time to time.

    • *****

      These open-faced sandwiches evoke spring any time of year. The mound of fava bean puree just screams freshness, and the flavor mingles happily with the crumbly Beyos cheese. A total delight.

    • ***

      Tía Pol’s tortilla is fine, and if you’re in the mood, go ahead and order one. However, your belly is better served by reserving space for some of their more intriguing, inspired options, instead of going with this passable rendition of an old classic.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    fun with friends
    My meal cost
    between $10 and $25
    I tipped
    between 15% to 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (4 of 4 people found this review helpful)  
    Add/Show Comments (2)
  • Alfama Add to Try List
    Jun 17, 2007 Link

    Romantic Portuguese in the West Village

    Alfama is not perfect. There have been times when I’ve found myself eating less than stellar specials, which for the price is pretty inexcusable. But the great list of Portuguese wines and the perfect execution of a number of standard dishes continue to draw me back here, as does the friendly management and good service. And it offers by far the best Portuguese food I’ve had in New York.

    The classic dishes, like the bacalhau and mariscada, are good bets for entrees, and the tastiest – and most dramatic – way to start the meal is definitely with the chouriço flambéed tableside in aguardente. I rarely have room for dessert after a meal at Alfama, but, when I do, the pillowy meringue with fruit, called farófias de nata, is definitely the way to go.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      Dramatic, intense, smoky, charred, and bursting with flavor. This is Alfama’s signature dish, and with good reason.

    • ****

      Cloud-like meringue piled into a cocktail glass with fruit. How could that help but be delicious?

    • ***

      Two or three of the cheeses were great, but the other two were nothing special. The bread that comes with it makes a nice vessel, though. It may only be disappointing to real cheese lovers – others may not want the adventure that this cheese plate lacks.

    Extras:
    I came here for
    no comment
    My meal cost
    between $25 and $50
    I tipped
    more than 18%
    Was this helpful?
    Yes No (4 of 4 people found this review helpful)  
    Add a Comment
  • Caracas Arepa Bar Add to Try List
    Jun 17, 2007 Link

    Authentic Venezuelan in a Cute (and Tiny) Spot

    Caracas Arepa Bar may not be big – in fact, its space overflows with people at peak hours, with conversations in Spanish and English taking place at high volume – but its flavors definitely are. The arepas here are fried, not baked, but they still achieve that special texture, not crumbly, not cakey, but soft and almost sweet inside and with a perfectly crisp exterior. Even better are the ingredients they stuff them with, from crumbly Latin cheeses to black beans, avocado, chorizo, and even perico, Venezuelan-style scrambled eggs (at brunch).

    The tequeños, a kind of fried cheese stick, make a good starter, but the guasacaca (Venezuelan guacamole) and homemade yucca chips will leave you better able to enjoy an arepa or two. Sadly, the empanadas are nothing special, and should be avoided in favor of the more unique items available.

    The chicha, a kind of thick horchata, and the banana shake are both great for washing everything down.

    What I ate:
    • *****

      Delicious classic brunch arepa, with scrambled eggs, cheese, avocado, and black beans.

    • Aphz7uhg0r3kraaby-gaa780x80
      ****

      Hard to drink an entire glass of this rice mixture, because it’s so thick, but great for sharing. It’s almost like dessert in a glass.

    • Dfutxyhgwr3lknaby-gaa880x80
      ****

      Great banana milk shake. A somewhat less filling option than the chicha.

    • Aznrh6hg0r3ilvaby-gaa780x80
      ***