Welcome to the New Buffalo restaurant dining guide! Here you'll find the best New Buffalo restaurants, as well as the newest and most recently reviewed New Buffalo-area restaurants.

Dine out using the New Buffalo restaurant reservations list or order in from New Buffalo food delivery restaurants.

Or, search to find what you're craving - you can filter results by restaurants with menus, take online reservations, or have online ordering.

Click to view the interactive map
9/18/2020

A dining patron from US tried Skip's Other Place.

8/17/2020

An American chowhound from Mishawaka, IN tried Skip's Other Place.

7/29/2020

A diner from US tried Skip's Other Place.

7/02/2020

An American chowhound from US tried Rosie's Restaurant.

6/18/2020

An American food lover from South Bend, IN tried Skip's Other Place.

6/16/2020

A dining patron from US tried Skip's Other Place.

6/14/2020

A dining patron from Saint Joseph, MI tried Roma Pizza.

5/22/2020

An Italian food lover from Michigan City, IN tried Brewsters Deli and Cafe.

5/15/2020

A dining patron from New Buffalo, MI tried Song Asian Cuisine, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

4/06/2020

A dining patron from New Buffalo, MI tried Villa Nova Pizzeria, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

Pros
I feel that they make the best pizza in town. I like thin crust and not too greasy. If that is your preference I recommend that you give this place a try. They do make other dishes and they have a nice bar area enclosed for the weather so it is also OK
Cons
Atmosphere is not the strong point but I do not say that to criticize. This is a Pizza place and they have a good kitchen. If I want to get kicked out for not wearing a tie and jacket I would go elsewhere.
Comments
I read some reviews that were submitted in the summer and I was saddened by the negative nature of some. This place is inundated in the summer and simply can't keep up. If it were in France they would simply say "No, no room, goodbye."
1/25/2020

An American food lover from US tried Skip's Other Place.

1/10/2020

An American chowhound from Euless, TX tried Skip's Other Place.

12/22/2019

A Pizza chowhound from Michigan City, IN tried Villa Nova Pizzeria, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and didn't like the ambiance.

Pros
Too expensive..50.00 for small pizza , 2 beers and 2 glasses wine...+ tip
12/07/2019

A dining patron from US tried Skip's Other Place and liked it.

11/15/2019

A diner from South Bend, IN tried Skip's Other Place and liked it.

10/05/2019

A dining patron from New Buffalo, MI tried Roma Pizza.

7/17/2019

A dining patron from Chicago, IL tried Casey's Bar and Grill.

6/04/2019

A diner from US tried Skip's Other Place.

5/07/2019

A diner from Deerfield, IL tried Skip's Other Place and liked it.

5/01/2019

An American chowhound from Elmwood Park, IL tried Skip's Other Place.

Red Arrow Roadhouse

Loved it. Relaxed atmosphere with a sports bar...

Loved it. Relaxed atmosphere with a sports bar feel. Service is great and the chef is willing to alter meals if necessary. (1)...

Pizza Hut

LARGE PAN SUPREME PIZZA

we have been customers of the new buffalo pizza hut for about 20 years, coming there because of the most delisious pizza's in...

Copper Rock

Copper Rock Rocks

While the Copper Rock is a bit pricey to say the least, it is a great place to eat for any very special occasion. We had the 14...

Villa Nova Pizzeria

Top Flight Pizza in Harbor Country

We read an article in the Chicago Sun Times about what they thought was excellent pizza in the SW suburbs. The place was called...

Red Arrow Roadhouse

Outstanding neighborhood restaurant

If you are a local, this is like the Cheers Bar. If you are visiting, you will be treated by friendly and enthusiastic staff....

See more New Buffalo restaurant reviews

Do you blog about dining in New Buffalo? Share your experiences with Menuism users!

Add your blog posts to this page »

  • Remember your favorite restaurants by saving it to your personal dining journal.
  • Read and write reviews on individual dishes, and upload your food photos for all to see.
  • Interact with local foodies with comments and Menuism mail.
  • View top rated dishes and online restaurant menus (we're the web's largest menu aggregator).

Sign Up

or


Have a Menuism account? Sign in first to link it.

People found this by searching for: Villa Nova Pizza New Buffalo, Bentwood Tavern New Buffalo, Roma Pizza New Buffalo, Skip's Other Place New Buffalo Michigan, Villa Nova Pizza New Buffalo Michigan, New Buffalo Restaurants, and Villa Nova Pizza New Buffalo Mi Menu.