Neil's Heritage House

Cuisine: American, Banquet Hall, Contemporary

Neil's Heritage House is a American, Banquet Hall, and Contemporary restaurant where most Menuism users came for a romantic date, paid between $25 and $50, and tipped more than 18%.

Offer Available!
"No pros"
"Food tasteless"
  • 8/29/2015

    An American food lover from Mokena, IL tried it.

  • 11/16/2014

    An American chowhound from Chicago, IL tried it.

  • 10/22/2014

    A diner from Chicago, IL tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

  • 7/27/2014

    A food lover from Newark, NJ tried it.

  • 12/26/2013

    An American chowhound from Bucyrus, OH tried it, didn't like it, and rated it . They didn't like the food, didn't like the service, and didn't like the ambiance.

    No pros
    Food tasteless
  • 7/13/2013

    A dining patron from Cleveland, OH tried it.

  • 6/18/2013

    A dining patron from Monroe, MI tried it.

Daytonfoodie photo


 Dayton, OH

Best restaurant in Dayton FABULOUS DELCIOUS must try

A group of us went to the pine club tonight. We were told the wait was going to be over an hour. I suggest we go to the New Neil’s. Everyone agreed so I called Neil’s and asked if they could accommodate a party of 8. They said no problem and we were on our way.
Believe it or not they had already set up a table as Soon as we arrived.

The host took us to the table and immediately we had water and fresh French bread. Soon after our waitress arrived and informed us about the specials. She then took our drink orders. After she delivered our several craft draft beers and many other cocktails…. Yes we drink a lot. She then took our orders. Since we were headed to the Pine Club we all ordered meat dishes. I ordered the beef Wellington and everyone else ordered the New York strip and the filet. As a group we ordered several appetizers to share. We selected the baked Brie, calamari, and the mushrooms pirouttes.
The baked Brie was the best absolutely to fantastic. It was wrapped with a homemade flaky pastry dough with sweet charred pear slice a top. The calamari was flash fried served with squid ink sauce with a hint of soy and ginger. Again, this was out of this world. Finally, the mushrooms were filled with bread crumbs and herbs as well as blue cheese and lightly sautéed in olive oil. Very unique, very tasty and excellent.
My wellington was just what I expected. It was cooked perfectly. As for the seven others there steaks were better than the pine club or the Oakwood club. What was especially great we’re the sides that the steaks came with. White cheddar mashed potatoes and Brussels sprout pedals. OMG, these sides make those old stewed tomatoes and soggy wilted vegetables at the pine club and Oakwood give new meaning to side dishes. They were fresh and delicious.

We all decided not to have dessert. Although, all the desserts served at Neil’s all are from Ashley’s in Oakwood and are especially made for Neil’s. I wish I had room but there is always next time.
Overall, I strongly would reccommend Neil’s to everyone. You will not be disappointed.


absolutely perfect. Better than the pine club or Oakwood club. Better than any steak within 100 miles. Cooked perfectly. I want another one right now.



So Neil’s Heritage House has been bragging up their organic garden which caused me to ask them the question " How do you have an organic garden? It takes years to get certified’ instead of answering the question they just deleted it and want to continue to mislead what few customers they have on what they are eating. Homegrown is NOT necessarily organic and you better get that right when you are selling to the public. Growers can state that their produce is naturally grown, pesticide free,chemical free, all-natural, etc., but cannot legally use the term “organic” unless they are certified." STOP CALLING IT ORGANIC!

American Dayton Kettering
Contact Business

Neil's Heritage House  Restaurant Reviews

Copy the link below and paste onto your website or blog to display badge.

People found this by searching for: Neil's Heritage House Dayton Ohio, Neil's Heritage House Dayton Ohio Menu, Beef Wellington Dayton Ohio, Neil's Heritage Housemenue, Menus Neils Heritage, Neils Heritage House, Neil's Heritage House Menu, and Neils Heritage House Menu.