Diner Survey Results 128 responses
"great food good prices"
"BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK"
"Cheese steaks and pizza are both very good. No ambiance and little effort at table service."
"Pizza is solid"
"amazing hoagie!! best in West Chester. Very good cheesesteaks as well."
"Fries cheese steaks. Pizza"
"Don't take credit or debit cards"
"Food was good and they are of friendly service"
"Cheesesteaks are the best within the area"
"Only take cash"
"Sometimes rude staff"
"Service staff is under 18 and inexperienced makes for poor service "
"Should get a register that accepts visa and master card "
"Don't accept credit cards"
"Decor and they dont accept credit cards"
"Try it you'll love it"
3 reviews of Pepper Mill, first by you?
Pepper Mill Articles — Things To Know Before You Go
Best Dishes at Pepper Mill
These dishes from the Pepper Mill menu are contributed by Menuism users directly, as part of a restaurant review, or as part of an image upload.
12 Inch American Hoagie
12 Inch American Grinder
12 Inch Bleu Combo Grinder
2/19/2017 A diner from Malvern, PA tried it.
2/06/2017 A diner from US tried it.
2/05/2017 A diner from West Chester, PA tried it and liked it.
1/30/2017 A diner from Wayne, PA tried it.
1/28/2017 A diner from US tried it.
1/18/2017 A diner from US tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.
1/18/2017 A diner from Louisville, KY tried it, didn't like it, and rated it . They didn't like the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.
- Waitress was nice
- Combo appetizer had limp onions rings and the broccoli and cheese poppers were also limp and soggy; taste was horrible. My husband's cheesesteak was dry and my sausage , peppers and onions was too spicy (I was told that it wasn't going to be spicy
- I was EXTREMELY disappointed. I have been here multiple times before, and never expected this. The only good thing was the ice cream
1/17/2017 A diner from West Chester, PA tried it.
1/16/2017 A diner from Malvern, PA tried it and liked it. They liked the food.
1/15/2017 A diner from Rossford, OH tried it.