707 Harden St
Columbia, SC 29205
Call

Pop's N.Y. Pizza

Neighborhoods: Five Points
Cuisine: Pizza, Cheesesteak, Sandwiches

Pop's N.Y. Pizza is a Pizza, Cheesesteak, and Sandwiches restaurant where most Menuism users came for a meal on the go and paid less than $10.

Offer Available!
Overall
100%
Food
100%
Service
100%
Ambiance
75%
Pros
"Amazing northern Pizza"
  • 1/27/2018

    A Pizza chowhound from Atlanta, GA tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

  • 4/22/2017

    A Pizza food lover from Lexington, SC tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

    Pros
    Amazing northern Pizza
  • 3/20/2016

    A Pizza food lover from US tried it and liked it.

  • 11/14/2013

    A Pizza food lover from FL tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

  • 3/15/2013

    A diner from Batesburg, SC tried it.

  • 3/09/2013

    A diner from Philadelphia, PA tried it and liked it.

    Pizza

    Photo by redpeyton Pizza is a food so beloved in the U.S. it seems like it’s been around forever, but there are some immediate clues that pizza as we know it today is a relatively new invention. ...read more

    Sandwich-300x200

    In the U.S., sandwiches are as ubiquitous as they are delicious. But it turns out that sandwiches, in all of their various, glorious forms, are popular all over the world. From Danish smørrebrød to...read more

VolleyballMom photo

VolleyballMom

 Lexington, SC
 

If all the NY-Style Pizza places close down, then...maybe...

My husband and I went to Pop’s a month or so after it first opened. It was excellent. The staff was a little “wet-behind-the-ears” and the service was a tad bit slower than we expected given there were only 4-5 customers present. But hey…we figured they were learning the ropes. Again, they just opened not too long ago. The pizza was excellent, reminding my husband and I of home (NY). Not quite the same, but close enough to quench the craving for NY-style pizza. Since then, I have gone back twice (July of this year and 2 days ago). Both latter visits, the staff was still clueless and the service was still horrible. 2 days ago, I paid for my order before noticing that the cashier (was she old enough to work legally??) took my order incorrectly. I asked for a refund of the difference and was told that no one in that entire place could or knew how to give refunds but the manager. Really?!! So, I wait for my pizza and the manager to come in from chatting outside. After 2 or 3 minutes, I see one of the other girls sit a box on the far side of the counter. I wait another 10 minutes and the same girl who sat the box on the far side asks me: what did you order? I told her…that WAS my box. You’ve got to be kidding me. I then wait for the manager to give me my refund of the difference (he grumbled the whole time) and I take my pizza and leave. The Pizza was substandard to say the least. It was burnt on the bottom (like it was in July when I went). I think they need to clean their oven or put the pizza on a timer. If the service was better, the staff more competent, and the pizza less charred, Pop’s would probably be the only place I’d go for pizza. But until then…If all the NY-Style Pizza places close down, then…maybe…but probably not.

orcabound photo

orcabound

 Columbia, SC
 

if you'd like to wait two hours for reheated pizza

Our experience with Pop’s pizza began with a phone call requesting delivery to a guy who asked for my phone number twice and then reported my address to the delivery driver as “East Squadron,” I live in West Quad. An hour and ten minutes after ordering, the delivery driver called, understandable confused about where East Squadron might be. He arrived twenty minutes later with a stone cold pizza. He had also forgotten to take the credit card receipt with him. He called his manager who took ten minutes to tell him that he couldn’t give us the pizza. At this point I spoke to the manager, Emily, and asked her to comp the pizza, cause this is well…ridiculous. Sadly she could only offer us a 30% discount on our NEXT purchase. At this point the driver left to get the receipt with the pizza. He returned half an hour later (2 hours ten minutes after ordering)with a reheated pizza and a full price ticket. So I ate pasta for dinner and would really like my 18 dollars back.

P.S. Emily, even though you’re related to the owners I hope you get canned!

cheese pizza

God awful! But then that’s probably because they had to stick it back in the oven when they returned to the restaurant to get the receipt.

ObjectiveReview photo

ObjectiveReview

 Columbia, SC
 

Pure Criminal

The food is not worth the price. They take advantage of college kids. The service is extremely slow. The management is in competent and the owner is a known criminal.

http://columbiacitypaper.com/?p=985

ABCD photo

ABCD

 Atlanta, GA
 

THIS PLACE IS TERRIBLE

What ever you do, do not go to POPS Pizza. It is one of the worst places in the history of food businesses. The service is terrible.The workers are horrible. I want to save everyone their money by not going to this place. It is a huge waste. Do not go here!!!!!!!!!

cheese pizza

TERRIBLE!!!!!!!!

JEANIE photo

JEANIE

 Columbia, SC
 

Only the food is good, I thought

This is the second time we ordered from Pops and were left disappointed. The first time the restaurant did not bother to tell us they did not have a delivery person and we ended up waiting 2 hours for lunch. The second time we sent someone to pick up our food and we were still missing a sandwich. When we called for the missing sandwich, they claimed someone was bringing it. Needless to say the poor young lady had to wait 4 hours for her sandwich because they kept forgetting to send it out with the driver. Sadly enough, during my wait I find out from the other young lady responsible for picking up our food that the restaurant was filthy. The very table used to make the pizza had a fly on it before the pizza dough was slapped down on it. If I had known the place was a filthy restaurant, I would have never ordered from there because now I just want to vomit that mess back up since it was filth that I ate anyway.

November 30, 2010
 

Overpriced and lackluster

I will say this, the crust was great... but that's where the praise ends.The place is a pit, the tables and chairs look like dump rejects someone picked up along the way and considering they are never cleaned, the fellas who work there…
April 25, 2010
 

Not the best pizza in Columbia.

I had an unfortunate experience the first time that I went to Pop's with a friend. The menu board was so worn that my friend and I thought we were ordering an 8-inch pizza, only to find that it was in fact an 18-inch pizza when it came to…

Read 8 reviews on Citysearch »

Tags
Pizza Cheesesteak BYOB
Website
Video
Hours
Contact Business

Pop's N.Y. Pizza  Restaurant Reviews

Copy the link below and paste onto your website or blog to display badge.

Pop's N.Y. Pizza is located near the cities of Market Center, West Columbia, Forest Acres, and Cayce.
People found this by searching for: Pop's Ny Pizza Columbia Sc Menu, Pizza Places In Five Points Columbia Sc, Pops New York Pizza, Pop's Ny Pizza Columbia, Pops Pizza Columbia Sc, Pops New York Pizza Columbia Sc, Pizza Joint Forest Acres, and Pops Ny Pizza Columbia Sc.