Diner Survey Results 10 responses
"The mac n cheese pizza is amazing. The place isn't always the cleanest but the food is amazing."
"The foods good, price is reasonable, interior needs updating and sometimes the clerks(older lady W/the accent) are rude. "
"Love their pizza, it's always been good for us!"
"The pizza is good and the garlic rolls are DELICIOUS "
"The tables weren't clean."
"Never had any issues, but its sad when they close for the summer :)"
"The owners are rude as shit..even to their employees. The older woman was nice one time a long time ago when I first started going. Have not had better than a mediocre experience since. Have dwindled to buying a slice once or twice per year as opposed to"
"I always try to go there when I'm in the neighborhood."
Recent Visitors to Sal's Pizza
- 11/22/2017
A diner from Milwaukee, WI tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.
- Pros
- Some of the most authentic pizza anywhere!! Totally delish!!
- Cons
- Can't think of anything that needs improving.
- Comments
- Amazing whole pies, great crust, toppings and service! Prices are perfect for what you get!
- 9/16/2017
A Pizza food lover from Milwaukee, WI tried it.
- 6/09/2016
A Pizza chowhound from US tried it.
- 4/30/2016
A Pizza food lover from Milwaukee, WI tried it.
- 4/10/2016
A Pizza chowhound from Lake Geneva, WI tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.
- Pros
- The mac n cheese pizza is amazing. The place isn't always the cleanest but the food is amazing.
- Cons
- The tables weren't clean.
- Comments
- I always try to go there when I'm in the neighborhood.
- 3/26/2016
A dining patron from US tried it, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, didn't like the service, and didn't like the ambiance.
- Pros
- The foods good, price is reasonable, interior needs updating and sometimes the clerks(older lady W/the accent) are rude.
- 2/07/2016
A dining patron from Milwaukee, WI tried it.
- 2/06/2016
Loris3 tried it, liked it, and rated it . Loris3 liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.
- Pros
- Love their pizza, it's always been good for us!
- Cons
- Never had any issues, but its sad when they close for the summer :)
- 1/11/2016
A Pizza chowhound from IL tried it.
- 12/29/2015
A Pizza food lover from Milwaukee, WI tried it, didn't like it, and rated it . They liked the food, didn't like the service, and didn't like the ambiance.
- Pros
- The pizza is good and the garlic rolls are DELICIOUS
- Cons
- The owners are rude as shit..even to their employees. The older woman was nice one time a long time ago when I first started going. Have not had better than a mediocre experience since. Have dwindled to buying a slice once or twice per year as opposed to
bwrighterbee
Great crust, iffy toppings
What keeps me coming back is the fantastic chewy crust. It is by far the best crust I have had anywhere in Milwaukee. That being said the toppings are second rate. The cheese is so-so and the sausage is just bad. I end up ordering pepperoni because it is one of their better choices. It is very likely I will continue getting pizza here and being sad the toppings are not a a better quality.
I ordered the lasagna and it was very good and a huge portion. It came with the saddest salad I have ever seen. As I recall it was lettuce sprinkled with sliced black olives.
So I guess you will be very pleased and then disappointed with some aspect of any meal they serve here. I wish they would up there game because they have the potential to be great.
Best Dishes at Sal's Pizza
View all dishesThese dishes from the Sal's Pizza menu are contributed by Menuism users directly, as part of a restaurant review, or as part of a photo upload.
-
Bacon Cheeseburger
-
Bbq
-
2 liter Bottles
- Tags
- Website
Recommended Nearby
Ward's House of Prime
Steakhouse in Juneau Town
Alem Ethiopian Village
Ethiopian in Juneau Town
The Capital Grille
American in Kilbourn Town
Sanford Restaurant
American in Lower East Side
Link to Sal's Pizza
Copy the link below and paste onto your website or blog to display badge.