Call

Settler's Bay

Cuisine: American

Settler's Bay is a American restaurant where most Menuism users came for a romantic date, paid between $10 and $25, and tipped less than 15%.

Offer Available!
badboyrr photo

badboyrr

 Lake Mills, WI
 

Oh My God!

The only thing worse than the service was the food, which was surpassed by the managements response to my concerns! (BEWARE: Hobby business run by a snooty rich trophy wife wannabe)

I don’t like being overcharged for poor food and then told top dine elsewhere when I speak to the owner, or owners girlfriend as the case may be…

Capping it all off was the waitress spilling food onto the nasty serving tray only to pick it up with her fingers and put it back on the plate! She did claim that her hands were clean though.

April 20, 2011
 

NEW OWNERS

No true review, just an update that this restaurant was sold and is now under the ownership of the same people who own The Mine Shaft. I know the bar is open, but not sure if it's open for food yet. It's one of the few restaurants left…
November 3, 2007
 

BEWARE!

How many ways can I say BAD? But then again if you like to being served something thats not as described in the menu, poorly made and presented, dropped and then picked up with the waitresses fingers (she swore they were clean!) and…

Read 3 reviews on Citysearch »

11/18/2017

A diner from Janesville, WI tried Main Street Cafe, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

11/14/2017

A Buffet chowhound from Janesville, WI tried China Buffet, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

11/01/2017

A dining patron from Janesville, WI tried Bamboo Kitchen.

10/28/2017

A diner from US tried Bamboo Kitchen, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

10/28/2017

A Pizza chowhound from Cottage Grove, WI tried Rose Garden Cafe & Pizzeria, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

Pros
Friendly atmosphere, waitress was very easy going and made you feel at home, no pressure, food was great, dining room was clean. We have been there three times and will be going back. No Cons
Cons
None
10/24/2017

A dining patron from Carmel, NY tried Sal's Pizza & Pasta, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

Pros
THIN CRUST PIZZA ABSOLUTELY DELISH
10/22/2017

A diner from Watertown, WI tried Taqueria Maria's.

10/20/2017

A diner from Oconomowoc, WI tried Phil's Pizza Palace.

10/13/2017

A dining patron from US tried La Finca DE Adobe, liked it, and rated it . They liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

10/12/2017

A diner from Watertown, WI tried El Mariachi Mexican Restaurant and liked it.

Tags
American
Website
Video
Hours
Contact Business

Settler's Bay  Restaurant Reviews

Copy the link below and paste onto your website or blog to display badge.

People found this by searching for: Settlers Bay Watertown, Settlers Bay Watertown Wisconsin, Settlers Bay Restaurant Watertown Wi, Settlers Bay Watertown Wi, Settler's Bay Restaurant In Watertown Wisconsin, Settler's Bay Watertown Wi, Setleters Bay Watertwon Wis, and Settlers Bay In Watertown Wi.