Pizza Man

 2597 N. Downer Ave
Milwaukee, WI

Pizzaman with party of six

When our party of six arrived for our reservation on a Saturday night, our table was ready for us. Pizzaman is a very fun and noisy place. If you’re looking for a quiet, romantic dinner, you won’t find it here.

Five of us had pizza, and one had baked French onion soup. Everyone was very happy with their pizza. The thin crust was delicious—not the kind with little cracker holes that tastes like cardboard. The French onion soup came with a VERY thick layer of gooey cheese on top. You almost need a scissors to cut that cheese!

Our waitress explained she was “new” when she couldn’t answer our questions about what beer they had and what their house wine was. She checked with the bartender and got back to us. We ordered desserts and coffee, but the coffee didn’t come until long after we had finished our desserts. Our waitress apologized for the wait and told us they were brewing a new pot.

Overall, the food was great, but the service not so much.

small pizza

Fresh-made thin crust. Order extra cheese if you like your pizza cheesy.

See all reviews

  • 10/01/2019

    Cookeleo tried Poco Loco Cantina.

  • 1/22/2019

    Cookeleo tried Genesis Family Restaurant and liked it.

  • 3/04/2018

    Cookeleo tried County Clare in Yankee Hill, liked it, and rated it . Cookeleo liked the food, liked the service, and liked the ambiance.

    Fresh ingredients, very good service.
    Very noisy when busy.
    Good Irish fare.

Log in to your Menuism account to leave a comment.

See all latest comments

I Dine In:
Favorite Food:
Favorite Cookbook:
Too many to list!
Last Meal: