New York Water Bagel Company

 542 Fischer Boulevard
Toms River, NJ

Don't Bother!!

Being a brand new operation, you would think this place would at least produce AVERAGE bagels. WOW, what a shocker! They were probably THE worst bagels I’ve ever had! And I’ve had bagels from the best locations in NJ (ie Watson Bagel in Irvington)! I bought a dozen mixed bagels, and first tried the everything bagel (my personal favorite). The bagel was undercooked, way too doughy, too much ready sponge and not enough seeds on it. I’ve gotten much better bagels at super markets and chains like Manhattan Bagel (there’s one right here in Toms River) Actually, the best bagels I’ve had in this area were from a small place called Terragani’s right down the street. Excellent bagels with pleasant wait staff and decent pricing. As for this place, its a MAJOR thumbs down!!

See all reviews

Log in to your Menuism account to leave a comment.

See all latest comments

I Dine In: