3106 James St
Syracuse, NY 13206


Neighborhoods: Eastwood
Cuisine: Italian, Pasta, Calzones

Siciliano's is a Italian, Pasta, and Calzones restaurant where most Menuism users came for a family meal, paid between $10 and $25, and tipped between 15% to 18%.

Offer Available!

    While Italian cuisine involves many meats, cheeses, seafood, and vegetables, most of us associate Italian cuisine first and foremost with pasta. Pasta comes in many shapes and sizes, and each shap...read more

LadySpaghetti photo


 Syracuse, NY

Yes, Siciliano's, it does make a difference!

The meat and cheese in the Italian sub were good, with nice shredded lettuce and tomato, but man you BLEW IT with that sub roll. What WAS that – an enriched hot dog bun? Blech. why bother with anything beyond baloney on that garbage?

Further and most importantly, dear Siciliano’s, you are an embarrassment to your name for serving alfredo sauce over penne. Please, for the love of all things Italian, if you run out of fettuccine, give your first/last time orderer the opportunity to switch up to marinara. Please inform your kitchen staff that it most certainly DOES make a difference. Or demonstrate by asking them to try to choke down that lump of flavorless concrete.

And who asked you to add chicken to my pasta anyway? Were those dry pieces of tree bark supposed to make up for some part of the aforementioned food tragedy? Oh yeah, and thanks for charging me two bucks for two tiny pieces of broccoli.

What a disappointment. The menu looked awesome.

JessiKay photo


 Syracuse, NY

Crooked? Debauched? Take your pick.

A few friends and I have been reading various restaurant reviews of places we’ve been to and we’ve caught onto something…..The only two positive reviews(On this site and a few others) for this “restaurant” were written BY the owner(What small business owner needs aliases??) In-fact anyone who has ever been in this place will probably recognize the picture of one of the reviewers. Guess who? Can we say shady? The issues with this “establishment” do not so much lay within the food but the conduct…But we decided to order anyway. Figured since we were starving that our best option was to go for low quality food with a good delivery time. We knew there wouldn’t be many orders ahead of us. We were right. It also doesn’t help that the owner has a well known rep for getting nasty with customers. Also the slices sign is a scam just to get you to come in and on more than one occasion they have made people pay extra because their menus “needed to be updated”.

pizza and wings

Foods not bad, it was somewhat edible. Pizza looked like it had been thrown around a bit in the car, way too much flour on the bottom, crust was pretty tasteless… They say there is garlic butter on it but I beg to differ and if there IS then a new recipe is in order. Cheese was mediocre, but at least the sauce was decent. Although we wished there was more of it. It’s clear they’re skimping on ingredients to save money. Quantity over quality applies well to the wings. They were dry with little taste but they were a pretty hefty size.

mike1973 photo


 Syracuse, NY

dont waste your time or money

We put are order in and where told 45 min for delivery,waited about 1hr and called to find out what the problem was.we where told that it was on the way and would be there in 5 min,after 20 more min it finnaly showed up(wish it never did)the wings where very dry with very little sauce,and for the pizza i thought i was back in school or it came from the gas station.do your self a favor and PASS…….

pizza and wings

very bad

johnt1 photo


 Syracuse, NY

great food

Ive been eating there since they open and just like everywhere that just open they had times of good and bad but for the last
10 months i order from there 2-3 times a week and its been awsome. No other shop make all the food to order. They make the sub rolls while you wait and who in syracuse has a diverse menu like them. The pizza is some of the best ive had and im sure anyone who eat there will agree and the owner is really nice and quick to correct anything thats wrong if somthing is wrong . Try thier pastas.

pizza and wings

great good food and pretty much on time all the time

pizzalover123 photo


 Syracuse, NY

very good

Had the wings also they were very wet actually not like the first review, Ive been ther 7 times now and everthing has been great.\Had 1 mistake on a pizza one time but the owner who is always there fixed it for me right away and told me to keep the other pizza so i had something to eat while they made the new one.
never had great service like that before. Big menu

Cajun chicken pasta

better them most upscale italian full service places. ive had a few diffrent pasta and they are all good and priced fair

Italian Delivery Takeout
Contact Business
Aunt Josie's

Italian in Washington Square

Number 1 Kitchen

Chinese in University

Aladdin's Natural Eatery

Middle Eastern in University Hill

Dinosaur Bar B Que

Bar in Downtown

Siciliano's  Restaurant Reviews

Copy the link below and paste onto your website or blog to display badge.

Siciliano's is located near the cities of Onondaga County, Lyncourt, Galeville, and Onondaga.
People found this by searching for: Siciliano Pasta Lasagna, Restaurants Eastwood Syracuse, Siciliano Gourmet Pizza Reviews, Best Lasagna In Eastwood, Siciliano's Gourmet Pizza, Siciliano's Gourmet Pizza Reviews, Sicilianos Syracuse, and Pizza Places Open Near Me 13206.